I have the 98 1/2 ton Chevy extended cab and at the same time I had an 88 S-10 with the four banger.
I prefer the full size over the compact pick up.
Remember the S-10/15 were "compacts" not midsize.
If you want something to play with look at the S-10 extreme. It's V-6 powered and has a little lower stance to start with over the standard S-10/15.
Stay away from the fours they are anemic as all get out.
If you look at the Dakotas go for the V8 the fuel savings of the V6 isn't worth the loss of HP.