That "extra gasket" is one of the Lower Intake Manifold gaskets. There is one on each end where the LIM meets the block. I hope you have one on each end or you will need to tear the LIM off again and install it!
_________________________
These are highly engineered precision vehicles, the first step in diagnosing the problem is to strike the suspected offending part sharply and repeatedly with a blunt object, then re-test.