I agree with ya Herc...there has always been a need for the big truck and always will be I'm sure but like you said, the majority of trucks today arent doing much of any heavy work at all.
I fault the auto industry for playing the whole "bigger is safer" which got many a household Mom into a big suv...while bigger is safer might well be true, "lets all start driving tanks" makes about as much sense.
I also like your term "placebo for safer" since the biggest truck on the planet doesnt make up for poor driver training or bad decision making.
I know I occasionally have the need of a truck but even then I dont need one that would pull the house. The Montana handles most all our hauling duties but some thing you dont want to throw back there. I like the concept of the Honda Ridgeline but the styling is just a bit too boxy for me (this coming from the guy who has the soft spot for an Aztek)